James Dumlao, a PhD student at Michigan, started his program in Fall 2022. His first first-author paper? Published Summer 2025 .
That's not a failure. That's the timeline.
Things nobody tells you:
A research paper is NOT a term paper. You are not proving you did the reading. You are educating the reader. If they are confused, that is feedback—not their fault .
If you're in the trenches with a desk-rejected manuscript, post below. We need a support group.
That's not a failure. That's the timeline.
Things nobody tells you:
- "Rejection is not a verdict. It's a noisy signal from an overworked volunteer."
- Reviewers disagree. One says "groundbreaking," one says "trivial." This is normal .
- You will cut 50% of your paper at least once. It will be better for it .
A research paper is NOT a term paper. You are not proving you did the reading. You are educating the reader. If they are confused, that is feedback—not their fault .
If you're in the trenches with a desk-rejected manuscript, post below. We need a support group.